“Uncovering Hidden Narratives in the Use of Unethical Geoscientific Research Practices: The Case of Parachute Science” (forthcoming) in Comprehensive Philosophy of Science (eds. Watkins A. & Ohnesorge, M.). Elsevier.
Abstract: Parachute science, research conducted in low and middle income countries without meaningful engagement with local scientists or communities, remains a persistent and ethically fraught practice in the geosciences. Despite widespread recognition of its harms, it continues to be justified through hidden narratives: implicit stories that frame collaboration as unnecessary and the advancement of science as a sufficient reason to overlook ethical obligations. This chapter examines how such narratives function, showing that they are both epistemically flawed and morally unjustifiable. They rely on false assumptions about local knowledge, misrepresent affected communities, and perpetuate patterns of scientific colonialism. Drawing on philosophy of historical sciences literature, I argue that hidden narratives often masquerade as legitimate explanations while failing to meet standards of coherence, causal reasoning, and contextual awareness, thereby generating harm for both local communities and the scientific enterprise itself. To counter these narratives, I propose a two-pronged approach. First, affected communities can develop counternarratives that reclaim their identities and expertise, making visible the details suppressed by dominant stories. Second, Western scientists can engage in meaningful, trust-based collaborations that expose and dismantle the false assumptions embedded in hidden narratives, thereby improving the quality of research and reducing extractive practices. Together, these strategies disrupt feedback loops that reinforce unethical practices, while promoting more ethical, inclusive, and epistemically robust geoscience. This analysis highlights that addressing hidden narratives is not merely a corrective measure, it is essential for advancing science that respects local knowledge, fosters equitable participation, and strengthens the integrity of research itself.
“Parachute Science in Paleontology as Distributive Epistemic Injustice” (2025). Philosophy of Science. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/psa.2025.10149
Abstract: Paleontology is facing an ethical crisis related to its long history of extractive practices, including a practice now referred to as parachute science. In this article, I provide diagnostic criteria for identifying parachute science and illustrate them using the high-profile example of a Brazilian dinosaur fossil, Irritator challengeri, acquired by a German museum under dubious conditions. I use this case study to identify three types of harm resulting from parachute science, showing how they can be understood as a case of distributive epistemic injustice. I conclude by using this framework to point toward more ethical paleontological practices.
“Are we in a Sixth Mass Extinction? The Challenges of Answering and The Value of Asking” (2025 [2022]) with Federica Bocchi, Alisa Bokulich, Gloria Grand-Pierre, and Aja Watkins. The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1086/722107
Abstract: In both scientific and popular circles, it is often said that we are in the midst of a sixth mass extinction. Although the urgency of our present environmental crises is not in doubt, such claims of a present mass extinction are highly controversial scientifically. Our aims are, first, to get to the bottom of this scientific debate by shedding philosophical light on the many conceptual and methodological challenges involved in answering this scientific question and, second, to offer new philosophical perspectives on what the value of asking this question has been—and whether that value persists today. We show that the conceptual challenges in defining ‘mass extinction’, uncertainties in past and present diversity assessments, and data incommensurabilities undermine a straightforward answer to the question of whether we are in, or entering, a sixth mass extinction today. More broadly, we argue that an excessive focus on the mass extinction framing can be misleading for present conservation efforts and may lead us to miss out on the many other valuable insights that Earth’s deep time can offer in guiding our future.
“Models, Data Models, and Big Data” (2024) with Alisa Bokulich in The Routledge Handbook of Philosophy of Scientific Modeling (eds.: Knuuttila, T. Carrillo, N, & Koskinen, R.). Routledge.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003205647-22
Abstract: This chapter discusses the complex and subtle relations between models and data in the production of data models. It highlights key data processing techniques, such as data correction and data conversion, which illustrate what is known as model–data symbiosis. Projects related to data rescue and other model–data practices, such as the reuse and repurposing of data, are examined. Some of the philosophical issues concerning big data are reviewed. The chapter concludes by examining current challenges in data ethics, including the risks associated with open data movements, privacy, and what is known as “dirty data.”
“Beyond Synthesis: Developing Geoethical Guidelines for Transdisciplinary Collaboration”
Abstract: In paleontology, interdisciplinary and transdisciplinary collaboration is often proposed as a remedy for parachute science, but it becomes difficult when incommensurable values or conflicting worldviews make knowledge synthesis impossible. The Myanmar amber debate illustrates this problem: after the 2021 military coup, the Society for Vertebrate Paleontology called for a moratorium on related publications, yet publications continue, and researchers disagree about whether to adopt a ban or a more nuanced, case-by-case approach. I ask how ethical guidelines for data collection and sharing can support collaboration across knowledge systems when synthesis is not feasible and collaborators' ethical priorities conflict, such as when one worries about exporting a fossil and another about local capacity to curate it. I propose that collaborators assess their options by evaluating likely consequences, including the distribution of benefits and harms and effects on relevant communities, which allows them to decide how to proceed without resolving their disagreement or ruling on which value or worldview is correct, and I apply this approach to the Myanmar amber case.
“Encoded Assumptions: How AI and Big Data Reshape Scientific Methodology”
Abstract: As AI tools become normalized in scientific practice, biases in their training data are increasingly built into the methods researchers use to generate and evaluate knowledge. I examine how AI is changing scientific methodology and what assumptions about data, evidence, and objectivity get encoded in the process. These assumptions often go unexamined because AI outputs appear neutral and technical, even though choices about what data to collect and whose experiences it represents carry ethical and epistemic weight. I develop this argument through a case study from paleontology: OneStrata, a supercomputer-run AI model that reconstructs the history of biodiversity through predictive modeling rather than fossil data alone. Shen et al. (2026) claim that OneStrata undermines the "Big Five" mass extinctions and argue that this model opens a path toward a “predictive digital Earth” for forecasting the planet’s future. I argue that this largely “black box” model fails to address data validation, a problem that becomes acute when outputs inform policy. OneStrata shows how replacing empirical records with prediction can quietly redefine what counts as evidence.
“Deep Time, Shallow Planning: Modeling the Long-Term Costs of Green Energy Mining”
Abstract: Green energy is often embraced as a solution to climate change, but the mining of land and ocean for the metals it requires sets off effects that may not become apparent for decades, centuries, or even geological timescales. In this paper, I ask how different models can help us anticipate and evaluate these long-term costs to biodiversity, ecosystems, and the Earth more broadly. I argue that the transition to clean energy has overemphasized its immediate benefits, a kind of shallow planning that treats short-term gains as the measure of success while neglecting the deep-time consequences of extraction. I propose that models attentive to long timescales can inform policies that balance the trade-offs of the transition while protecting both human and non-human populations and the long-term health of the Earth.